What's wrong to write g for 漢語拼音 pronunciation of 歌?

Chinese Grammar
 
  Nov 08  •  279 read 
This is a question asked on behalf of thousands of new beginner learning 漢語拼音. When giving a 漢語拼音 dictation test (like spelling test in English) to my students, one very smart student write "g" for my pronunciation of 歌. When I pointed out it's wrong, he argued: "you taught us HYPY "g" is pronounced as 歌/哥. So when I heard you pronounced 歌 and I wrote "g". What's wrong with that?" How can I reply? Especially knowing it is the biggest flaw if 漢語拼音 teaching.
0
0
0
Answer

元音有韵,辅音无韵。is a fundamental phonetic concept. Since HYPY barrowed English alphabets as its symbols, it should stick to the separation of the "names" of the letters and the pronunciation of the letters in spelling. The name of letter "b" is "bee", but the pronunciation is very short bursting solid sound of both lips, without any "vowel" involved. When teaching 辅音,all the material pronounced either with "e" or "o" rhyme. Wrong! Unless you remind your students that you are introducing the "names" of the symbols, followed by the right pronunciation in spelling, i.e. 辅音无韵。 Thus 歌 is rhymed, must be spelled "ge" as "e" contributes the rhyme.

Is it that the teaching method is so authoritative that no one ever pointed out its flaw? BTW, what's wrong with 声母 and 韵母 that they must be changed to 辅音 and 元音?

(more)
 0  •  Reply •  Nov 08
More
ID: 1255

Ali

Offline
Jul 30  Visited
From Islamabad, Pakistan
Send Message
Related
I uploaded "Lexicon of Reconstructed Pronunciation", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3111I uploaded "Wrong, Wrong, Wrong! (Level 1, Russion)", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3908瓜茎 的拼音?I uploaded "Winning in China - Pronunciation", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3155I uploaded "Glossika Chinese Pronunciation and Tone Training", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3813拼音字幕学习中文就像一场马拉松,不是短跑,而是需要耐心和毅力的长久旅程。一开始可能会觉得声调很难、汉字复杂,甚至有时候想放弃……但请记住,每一个现在流利说中文的人,都曾经历过和你一样的阶段。 每天进步一点点,哪怕只多记一个词、多读一句话,都是值得骄傲的成就。试着把中文融入生活:听中文歌时看看歌词,看剧时模仿对话,甚至用中文写日记或发朋友圈。这些小事会让学习变得更有趣、更自然。 遇到困难时,不要对自己太苛刻。学习语言本来就是一个不断犯错、不断修正的过程。错了吗?没关系!下次再来。 坚持,比完美更重要。 有一天,当你突然发现自己能听懂一句歌词、看懂一段字幕,或者和中国人流畅地聊上几句时——你会感谢今天没有放弃的自己。 一起加油吧!我们都在路上!💪✨I uploaded "The Wrong Shoes (Ages 8-13)", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3208拼音表Emiliaclarke is a technology enthusiast and a writer. I am interested to write articles related to technology, software, Mobiles, Gadgets and many more. https://www.techtodayworld.com/write-for-us/