How to say 孝 in English?

Learn Chinese
 
  Nov 07  •  234 read 
How to say 孝 in English? It is be nice and somewhat comply to parent. But how to say it in English? Former discussion mentions about filial piety, but I am not sure. It looks like a rare and unpopular word, despite it may explain it precisely. In Disney movie Mulan, it translates to devotion to family. That's definitely a mistake. I bet Disney just choose a similar but popular virtue to make it easier to understand. Maybe there is just no such a virtue, and not even a word for it in Western culture?
0
0
0
Answer

I submit that 孝 is a very Chinese concept. (It is possible that other ethnic groups in other parts of the less developed World may have similar concept, but not in present day Western societies, hence the difficulties here)

Translating it to mean mere "respect", "devotion to family", "love", does not capture it completely.

The very strict "practice" of 孝, ("practice" because the only way that 孝 could be shown or understood is by the "actions" or "conduct" of the children vis-a-vis their parents), applies even if the children do not love or respect or devoted to their parents because, regardless, it is incumbent upon the children to:-

look after their parents in old age;

to wear for a number of years certain mourning insignia on their arms to mourn their dead parents; and of course a proper if not grand burial;

to accept without question the parent's choice of the children's spouses;

generally to defer to the views of the parents on most issues governing the household which in most parts are patriarchal;

...and other practices which are peculiar to certain dialect groups.

Thus 孝 is not just an abstract concept, it is the practice of well-defined courses of actions or strictly prescribed conduct which the children must perform, in most cases publicly, to show 孝.

If there is 孝 from children to parents, there will, by natural extension, be 孝 in society in general, and upwards towards the Emperor and from him to Heaven and there will, therefore, be peace and harmony in the Universe.

So, the ancient argument goes, if there is not even any 孝 in a nucleic family unit, how could there be peace and harmony anywhere?

(more)
 0  •  Reply •  Nov 07
More
ID: 1255

Ali

Offline
Jul 30  Visited
From Islamabad, Pakistan
Send Message
Related
How to say when the food has gotten bad -1 -当一些食物坏了,用中文普通话怎么说? - YoutubeHalo, saya dari Indonesia. Sudah setahun belajar Bahasa Mandarin, dan saat ini saya masih di HSK 3. Mari kita belajar bersama~I uploaded "Lithuanian English Chinese Illustrated Dictionary", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3274I uploaded "Chinese Saying 1 (Traditional)", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/2944I uploaded "English Chinese Illustrated Dictionary", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/3303Reading exercise for HSK5 textbook 4 (子路背米) I have designed some questions for this passage and I hope these question will be helpful. HSK5:主人为什么要多给子路一些银子? A、子路很孝顺,他地孝心感动了主人 B、他想让子路给他多干活 C、主人算错了工钱 D、子路干活勤快、主人很喜欢 HSK5:子路为什么要给父母背米? A、子路很勤快,多挣到了银子 B、父母想让子路给他们买米和好吃的 C、子路很有孝心,想到父母从未吃饱过饭感到很惭愧,想让父母吃顿饱饭 D、主人多给了子路银子让他给父母买些米和鱼肉 HSK5:子路为什么能在出国做官? A、子路很孝顺 B、子路很勤快 C、楚国国君认为子路很有才能 D、子路背米感动了楚国国君 HSK6:子路为什么在出国做官后为什么没有因为待遇好而开心? A、子路不喜欢物质条件 B、子路思念他的父母,想到父母不能和他一起享受 C、子路不满足于在楚国当官的待遇 D、子路其实很开心 HSK6:这篇文章告诉我们的道理是? A、多劳多得 B、孝顺的人可以找到好工作 C、孝顺的人父母高兴 D、百善孝为先I uploaded "Russian English Chinese Business Dictionary", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/2770It is fun to be a Chinese teacher to teach my native language to the non-Chinese speakers. There are a lot words and expressions, which have been used without any second-thoughts, astonish me from time to time. For example, "有点儿“and "一点儿”, it has never occurred to me that "有点儿“ expresses a tone of unsatisfactory. "怎么走“和“怎么去”, one is to ask about the route and one is to ask the manner of transportation. At the same time, it is also fun to see that students from all over the world are fascinated in the long Chinese history and the unique pictograph Chinese Characters. Someone says Chinese is difficult, however there are still many "foreigners" who can speak very proficient Chinese. It is up to the persistence and perseverance.I uploaded "Chinese Saying 5 (Traditional)", enjoy it. https://www.cchatty.com/pdf/2951how to say“五官”