How accurate is CNN's (or Google Translate's) translation of 把全部心思和精力放在备战打仗上 as “put all our minds a

Learn Chinese
 
  Nov 07  •  705 read 
I quote the following CNN article:

Chinese President Xi Jinping has called on troops to "put all (their) minds and energy on preparing for war" in a visit to a military base in the southern province of Guangdong on Tuesday, according to state news agency Xinhua.

During an inspection of the People's Liberation Army Marine Corps in Chaozhou City, Xinhua said Xi told the soldiers to "maintain a state of high alert" and called on them to be "absolutely loyal, absolutely pure, and absolutely reliable."
Ben Westcott, Chinese President Xi Jinping tells troops to focus on 'preparing for war', CNN, 14 October 2020.

The CNN article links directly to the source, from which I quote the relevant parts:

习近平指出，要把全部心思和精力放在备战打仗上，保持高度戒备状态。……

习近平强调，要坚持党对军队绝对领导，加强党的创新理论武装，狠抓全面从严治党、全面从严治军，确保部队绝对忠诚、绝对纯洁、绝对可靠。……
习近平视察海军陆战队, Xinhua News, 13 October 2020.

Except for the word "(their)" CNN's translations from this article are identical to the result from Google Translate:

[Google Translate:] Xi Jinping pointed out that we must put all our minds and energy on preparing for war and maintain a state of high alert.

[Google Translate:] Xi Jinping emphasized that it is necessary to uphold the party's absolute leadership over the military, strengthen the party's innovative theoretical arms, pay close attention to comprehensively and strictly govern the party and the military, and ensure that the troops are absolutely loyal, absolutely pure, and absolutely reliable.

So it appears as if CNN used Google Translate here. However, there's some important nuance in the first part (the other parts seem unproblematic): "preparing for war" sounds rather different to "being prepared against war". It comes from 备战打仗 which seems to mean something like "ready for war":

备战 = "prepared against war / to prepare for war / warmongering"
打仗 = "to fight a battle / to go to war"
Particularly unexpected for me is the "-ing" suffix (in "preparing") since 备战打仗 doesn't seem to be used as a verb in the 放在……上 grammar structure.

Question: How accurate is CNN's (or Google Translate's) translation of 把全部心思和精力放在备战打仗上 as "put all our minds and energy on preparing for war"?
0
 
0
 
0
Answer
Shakoor

1

Don't all countries rattle sabres? Don't all countries 'prepare for war'?

'Prepare for war' is ambiguous. It either means 'prepare to be attacked' or 'prepare to attack'. Politicians like to leave things dangling.

In my opinion, the translation is flawed and biased.

Xi Jinping pointed out,
习近平指出，

要把全部心思和精力放在备战打仗上，
(we) must put all our thoughts and energy into preparing for battle,

保持高度戒备状态。
into maintaining a high state of alert.

习近平强调，
Xi Jingping stressed,

要坚持党对军队绝对领导，
we must persevere with our party's unconditional leadership of the armed forces,

加强党的创新理论武装，
strengthen our party's innovative theory division,

狠抓全面从严治党、全面从严治军，
pay close attention to maintaining strict discipline in our party and our armed forces,

确保部队绝对忠诚、绝对纯洁、绝对可靠。
and ensure our troops are absolutely loyal, reliable and in immaculate condition.

The Party cares about the Chinese people. I cannot believe that Xi Jingping, or China, would ever prepare for an offensive war. But every country must prepare its defence. Anything else is negligence.

(more)
 0  •  Reply •  Nov 07
More
ID: 1255

Ali

Offline
Jul 30  Visited
From Islamabad, Pakistan
Send Message